2022 Student-Authored Paper Award Outcome

2022 Student-Authored Paper Award Outcome

The Council of the American Genetic Association has reached a decision regarding the Journal of Heredity Outstanding Student-Authored Paper Award (formerly the Stephen J. O'Brien Award) for manuscripts published during 2021. This year, eleven articles in Volume 112 that were first-authored by a student were considered, and the award presented to Sheela Turbek for her paper, Variable Signatures of Selection Despite Conserved Recombination Landscapes Early in Speciation (Sheela P Turbek, Georgy A Semenov, Erik D Enbody, Leonardo Campagna, Scott A Taylor). JHered 2021. 111-6, pp 485–496.  

The evaluation committee had the following comments on this top-ranked article:

“Rarely do studies focus on the confounding role that variable recombination rates across the genome might play in shaping patterns of genomic differentiation. This reads like a tour de force describing the factors linking recombination and landscapes of genomic differentiation.”

Sheela will receive a $2,000 prize, a certificate, and up to $1,500 toward expenses to attend and present a talk at the 2022 AGA President’s Symposium.


Study Summary and Importance:

Genetic recombination plays an essential role in evolution by generating new nucleotide

combinations upon which natural selection can act. A growing body of literature indicates that

recombination rate can vary widely across the genome, and that this variation in turn influences

estimates of genomic differentiation (e.g., FST) often used to identify loci under divergent

selection. However, our understanding of the association between patterns of recombination and

landscapes of genomic differentiation during the earliest stages of the speciation process remains



This study took advantage of population genomic data from two avian radiations (southern

capuchino seedeaters and white wagtails), which have rapidly diversified in mate preferences

and genes encoding plumage coloration, to investigate the location of divergence peaks involved

in species differences in relation to fine-scale patterns of recombination. The study found that the

few narrow regions of elevated genomic divergence that differentiate closely related lineages

tend to fall in genomic regions of relatively low recombination. These results suggest that the

location of divergence peaks underlying plumage differences in areas of low recombination may

have protected these regions from the effects of gene flow, allowing diversification to proceed in

these rapid radiations. In addition, the study highlights the importance of considering the

confounding effect of variation in recombination rate when interpreting patterns of elevated

genomic differentiation early in the speciation process.



Sheela Turbek is a postdoctoral researcher with Dr. Kristen Ruegg at Colorado State University.

In 2021, she obtained her PhD in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology from the University of

Colorado Boulder, where she studied the mechanisms that generate and maintain biodiversity.

About the Journal

Journal of Heredity cover

View Current Issue

Issue 113-5 now online!

Read the Editor's Choice,

by Ochoa et al.

Freely available


Graphical Abstracts

Journal of Heredity is pleased to now offer multimedia graphical abstracts.

Authors can use the free online tool Tidbit to create attractive visuals. Include a graphical abstract with your submission!


AuthorsJournal of Heredity has

  • No page or color charges

  • Free data archiving in Dryad

  • Discounted open access for AGA members

Submit your manuscript

AGA Member Benefits:

  • Free Journal of Heredity access and discounted Open Access
  • Eligibility for awards
  • Discounted symposium registration and access to presentation videos
  • AGA Newsletter
  • Supporting a society that supports your community


Join the AGA or renew your membership

Any questions?  Contact the Managing Editor at theaga@theaga.org.


Read the AGA Council's statements on diversity - see About the AGA.